Fresh bagels, indie pizzas, and more made daily in NYC.

New York's
best bagels,
indie pizzas
& more

From fresh New York bagels and signature spreads to indie pizzas, sandwiches, and everyday favorites, Bagel Shop brings comforting flavor and fast service to the Upper East Side.

Welcome to

Bagel Shop

Welcome to Bagel Shop, a neighborhood spot serving fresh New York bagels, coffee, sandwiches, and everyday favorites in the Upper East Side. From classic bagels with cream cheese to hearty breakfast and lunch options, everything is made to be fresh, satisfying, and easy to enjoy.

Whether you’re stopping by in the morning, grabbing a quick bite, or ordering for pickup or delivery, Bagel Shop brings classic NYC flavor, fast service, and comforting favorites to every visit.

Order Online

Delivery

Takeout

Dine In

Bold Flavors

Healthy Options

Fresh New York Flavor

Bagels, Sandwiches & More

From fresh bagels and classic cream cheese spreads to coffee, breakfast sandwiches, lunch favorites, indie pizzas, and everyday bites, Bagel Shop delivers a casual New York dining experience built around freshness, comfort, and fast service. Every order is made to feel simple, satisfying, and full of flavor, whether you’re starting your morning, grabbing lunch, or ordering something quick to enjoy on the go. With classic bagel shop favorites and plenty of options for any craving, Bagel Shop makes every visit easy, fresh, and delicious.

Learn More

Made Fresh. Served Fast.

New York Bagel Favorites

At Bagel Shop, every order is made with fresh flavor, quick service, and classic New York comfort in mind. From bagels with cream cheese and hot coffee to breakfast sandwiches, lunch favorites, indie pizzas, and everyday bites, our menu is made to be simple, satisfying, and easy to enjoy. Rooted in the feel of a neighborhood bagel shop, Bagel Shop brings people together over fresh, familiar, and flavorful food.

View Menu

A glimpse of our flavors.

Our gallery

Check out our most recent reviews

What Our Customers Are Saying

Bagel Shop place picture
Bagel Shop
4.7
Based on 1492 reviews
powered by Google
review us on
Eli profile picture
Eli
15:13 24 Jun 26
They absolutely aced a group order for a production crew, delivered and packed with care, they were also very helpful and friendly over the phone , alrhough not listed online they do have boxes of coffee which really helps for a working crew order. Cream cheeses were great, Bagels were fresh and tasty! Thank you guys!
Ruben Bakke profile picture
Ruben Bakke
14:57 23 Jun 26
Best bagels in NYC! 🥯 The staff is awesome and the bagels are dangerously good. I’ve had the “Hail Caesar” 3 out of the last 4 days… and honestly I’m not even sorry. See you tomorrow.
Saheli Kothari profile picture
Saheli Kothari
01:54 22 Jun 26
Great variety, very accommodating, owner and staff are extremely nice.
Vegetarian and vegan friendly!

Flatty bagels have become a fave!
Veej Pal profile picture
Veej Pal
16:36 20 Jun 26
My family of 9 enjoyed their food and the service was great!
Jorge Lopez profile picture
Jorge Lopez
21:18 02 Feb 26
Bagels always fresh. I prefer them not toasted so warm and fresh and soft. The Mexi-kale salad with the jalapeno cilantro dressing is amazing, chicken or steak doesn't matter, I promise you. Quality is superior, food is delicious, customer service is superb. I would always recommend this spot if you want some good good food.
Alyssa Amoils profile picture
Alyssa Amoils
22:30 31 Dec 25
Came here for the first time and it was delicious! I had the pesto breakfast sandwich which was amazing and a super generous portion (a ton of eggs and avocado). Very bright and open space, nice seating and super friendly staff! The staff were all patient, kind, and very helpful (and during the lunch rush). Excited to come back and try more / try a bagel plain.
Jane Ahmon profile picture
Jane Ahmon
17:39 17 Dec 25
As good as absolute bagels! Delicious bagels at good price (mine was $4.65), full of flavour and toasted beautifully. Love the christmas atmosphere, quick with food, friendly, great music, big and spacious, and very crowded. Highly recommend for any occasion!
Petrit K profile picture
Petrit K
21:51 16 Dec 25
Best bacon egg and cheese on a toasted roll I ever bought : so much flavor. You can eat-in, you can order online, you can order in shop. They are fast, they are kind, and the food was so tasty. I’ll come here again whenever I’m in the area. Thanks!

Find us near you

Our Location

Bagel Shop, New York, NY

Address
Contacts
Hours
  • Mon-Fri: 7AM-4PM
    Sat-Sun: Closed
Check directions

Answers Before Your Next Visit

Frequently Asked Questions

We are known for fresh New York bagels, classic cream cheese spreads, hot coffee, breakfast sandwiches, lunch favorites, indie pizzas, and everyday bites. From toasted bagels and hearty sandwiches to quick grab-and-go options, every order at Bagel Shop is made with fresh flavor, fast service, and a classic neighborhood feel.
We serve fresh New York favorites throughout the day, with a menu focused on bagels, cream cheese spreads, hot coffee, breakfast sandwiches, lunch options, indie pizzas, and quick everyday bites. From toasted bagels and hearty sandwiches to simple grab-and-go favorites, every meal is made with fresh flavor, fast service, and a classic neighborhood bagel shop feel.

Yes, we offer Delivery and Takeout

We proudly serve the Upper East Side, Yorkville, Carnegie Hill, and surrounding Manhattan neighborhoods. Whether you’re stopping by, picking up takeout, or ordering delivery, Bagel Shop brings fresh New York bagels, sandwiches, coffee, indie pizzas, and everyday favorites to customers throughout the area.